Gluten Free Peanut Butter M&Ms Cookies #BakingIdeas


There’s no secret that my house has a sweet tooth–the entire family does!

We found this delicious peanut butter cookie recipe and even though not everyone in the family is gluten free, it’s everyone’s favorite! The only thing that could make it better was… you guessed it–M&Ms.

We have a tradition of making peanut butter cookies for a friend every year on his birthday. This year we decided to try a flourless cookie recipe with some added Plain M&Ms. We grabbed all of the ingredients except for the peanut butter at our new Walmart. The boys went a little crazy over all of the different types of M&Ms that were there:

M&Ms At Walmart #shop

Gluten Free Peanut Butter M&Ms Cookies


Gluten Free Peanut Butter M&Ms Cookies #shop #BakingIdeas #cbias

You’ll need:

Gluten Free Peanut Butter M&Ms Cookies #shop 1C peanut butter

1C sugar (I mix white and brown, 1/2C each)

1 egg

1tsp baking soda

1 1/2C plain M&Ms, divided into 1C and 1/2C portions

Let’s make some cookies!

1. Add all ingredients except M&Ms together in a large bowl.

2. Grab a few M&Ms from the 1C bowl, eat them.

3. Mix ingredients using a stand mixer or by hand.

4. Repeat step 2.

5. Add the 1/2C bowl of M&Ms to the mixture and mix by hand (so they don’t break in the stand mixer). The batter will look like this, and that’s ok:

Gluten Free Peanut Butter M&Ms Cookies #shop

6. Repeat step 2.

7. Using a spoon, take a scoop mixture and then use your hands to roll it into a tight ball. Place on a cookie sheet. I use a stone, so that’s what you see here.

8. Bake at 350* for 8-10 minutes. It’s a little tricky to see these cookies getting browned in the oven because of their color. Just keep an extra eye on them. This is what mine looked like when they were done:

Gluten Free Peanut Butter M&Ms Cookies #shopRepeat step 2. Repeat step 2. Repeat step 2.

When you remove the cookies from the oven, let them sit for 10-15 minutes so they cool and form together a little more.

Gluten Free Peanut Butter M&Ms Cookies #shop

 You can find other fun M&Ms recipes at, and you find find a coupon here.

Right now there is a fun Baking is Better with M Pinterest Sweepstakes going on for M&M’s! Pin for a chance to win one of three $250 Walmart gift cards! It’s as easy as submitting your email and pinning an image. Simply complete the following steps:

1. Enter your email in the form below and click “Enter”
2. Pin the contest image to any of your own Pinterest boards
3. Visit the Baking with M Pinterest board and Re-Pin your favorites to enter

Three (3) Winners will be selected at random – One (1) entry per person. Contest runs 12/06/13 – 12/31/13




  1. 1
    Kristy says:

    I’m gluten free too, so I love finding a new gluten free cookie to try! Thanks for sharing! #client

  2. 2
    Cameron says:

    Totally going to try it…however substituting the Peanut Butter with SunButter. :)

    Peas Out!

  3. 3
    mary says:

    Just made these but I didn’t have enough peanut butter. I substituted some almond butter and coconut. OMG yum. Gotta try the M&Ms some time! Yummo.

  4. 4

    […] Gluten Free Peanut Butter M&Ms Cookies | Source: My Crazy Good […]

Leave a Reply

Affiliate Links:

A Small Orange Shop Amazon
POGO Pass Promo Code
Health & Fitness
Parent Movie Reviews
Parent Auto Reviews

Visit my top posts:

Running Tips
Printable phone contracts for tweens and teens
Shakeology Recipes
Basic Burlap Wreath Tutorial
21 Day Fix Recipes
Dangerous Apps for Teens and Tweens
What I wish I knew before that post went viral


Site Disclosure and Privacy Policy