Buffalo Cauliflower Mac And Cheese

Buffalo Chicken anything is usually a big hit in our house, so I was excited to try out this recipe for the entire family. It’s a tasty and healthy buffalo cauliflower mac and cheese recipe, and a great way to get in some extra protein and veggies!

The great thing about making this spicy cauliflower mac and cheese with chicken is that it’s got a boost of protein, which is perfect for any healthy eating plan. I love that it’s a full meal in one pot when using the Instant Pot, but it can also be made on the stovetop or in a Crockpot.

The heat level for this recipe is a solid 2.5/5–it’s medium heat, not too spicy. It’s a delicious Buffalo Chicken Mac and Cheese recipe that the entire family can eat. If your kids like spicy foods, you could definitely increase the amount of hot sauce in this recipe.

Where’s the recipe?

Here at My Crazy Good Life, we write recipes that anyone can follow, whether you’re new in the kitchen or have been cooking for a bit! In the post below, you’ll find ingredient information and details cooking instructions, along with recipe tips and healthy eating plan information for diets like WW, the 21 Day Fix, and 2B Mindset.

If you’re just looking for the recipe, head straight down to the bottom where you’ll see the ingredient measurements and cooking instructions (three different ways!) for this Buffalo Cauliflower Creamy Macaroni and Cheese recipe!

Ingredients in Buffalo Cauliflower Mac & Cheese

• Olive Oil: I always aim for coconut, avocado, or olive oil. I try to stay away from highly processed oils like vegetable.
• Chicken Breast: Cut into small bite sized pieces for the Instant Pot and Stovetop versions, but left whole if you’re using the Crock Pot.
• Spices: A hint of ranch seasoning spices to complement your hot sauce and creamy base–you’re essentially making your own buffalo wings sauce.
• Cauliflower: I use a full head for this recipe, and it cooks so fast–cauliflower rice can be used, but it tends to come out a little mushy. I love the extra texture you get with full cauliflower florets.
• Hot sauce: Simple hot sauce, like Frank’s. Not buffalo sauce, as it has many more processed ingredients and oils. Regular hot sauce plus the spices in this recipe will still give you a buffalo style cheese sauce that’s delicious!
• Cottage cheese: Hear me out on this–blending together the cottage cheese and Greek yogurt will give you a protein packed and creamy buffalo cheddar cheese sauce for this recipe! Much healthier than heavy cream that’s typically called for in a recipe like this.
• Greek yogurt
• Cheddar Cheese
• Brown Rice Flour: This is used as a thickener, and can be substituted with other thickeners you may have in your pantry. Whole wheat or all purpose flour work!

How to make Buffalo Mac and Cheese in the Instant Pot

1. Turn the Instant Pot to Sauté. Add the oil and allow it to heat up. When the oil is hot, add the chicken and sauté until the chicken is browned.
2. Add garlic powder, onion powder, black pepper, dill, and parsley to the pot. Mix up the chicken so that the seasoning is evenly distributed.
3. Add the cauliflower to the Instant Pot and cover with the hot sauce. The hot sauce acts as your liquid for this recipe. Close the lid and turn the pressure valve to sealing.
4. Cook the chicken and cauliflower on high pressure using the manual setting for 1 minute. Let the pressure release naturally for 3-5 minutes before manually releasing it. This means that after the pot is done cooking, allow it to sit without touching it for 3-5 minutes. The contents will still be cooking. After that time, move the Sealing valve to the Vent position and allow the steam to come out. *See recipe tips section if you’re nervous about overcooking the cauliflower.
5. In a high speed blender, mix together the cottage cheese and Greek yogurt to create a creamy sauce. I know it’s difficult for some to trust the Greek yogurt/cottage cheese blend–trust me. The blending will remove the chunks from the cottage cheese and take that tangy taste out of the yogurt.
6. Blend the sauce until smooth, then pour the sauce over the chicken and cauliflower. Add the cheese and brown rice flour. Carefully fold the sauce and cheese in so that the cauliflower holds its shape.
7. Garnish and serve while still warm, or pack up for lunch through the week.

Note: For this buffalo cauliflower mac and cheese to work you must cut the chicken into small bite sized pieces and brown the chicken. If you skip this step the chicken will not have enough time to cook. Plus, it keeps the chicken from cooking in a solid lump.

How to make Buffalo Mac and Cheese on the stove

1. Heat a large skillet on the stove and add the olive oil. When the oil is hot, sauté the chicken until it is browned.
2. Add the seasonings, hot sauce, and cauliflower to the skillet. Mix it up so the cauliflower is covered in hot sauce. Cover the skillet and reduce heat to medium low heat.
3. Allow the cauliflower and chicken to cook for 5-10 minutes, stirring occasionally until the cauliflower is tender.
4. Blend together the cottage cheese and Greek yogurt to make a cream sauce. Remove the cauliflower and chicken from the heat when it’s cooked.
5. Stir the sauce, cheddar cheese, and brown rice flour into the skillet until the cheese melts. Garnish and serve.

How to make this in the Crock Pot

*Do not cube the chicken before cooking in the slow cooker.*

1. Add the whole chicken breast, cauliflower, seasoning, and hot sauce to the slower cooker.
2. Cover and let cook for 2 1/2 to 4 hours on low heat or until the chicken is done.
3. Remove the chicken, chop it into cubes, then add it back into the slow cooker.
4. Blend together the cottage cheese and Greek yogurt to make a cream sauce. Add the cream sauce, cheddar cheese, and brown rice flour to the chicken and cauliflower and mix until the cheese is melted. Garnish and serve.

Recipe Tips and FAQs

1. Can I make this with fresh riced cauliflower? Yes! You’ll want to quick release the pot. Just know it won’t have the same macaroni and cheese texture that the whole cauliflower florets have–it will taste a bit mushy.
2. Can I use pasta instead of cauliflower? You can, but I recommend a few changes. First, use larger chunks of chicken so they don’t become overcooked. Also, look to the back of the pasta box for your cooking time–you’ll want to cook it for half the lowest amount of time as listed on the back of the box.

• Optional garnish and toppings: diced green onion, breadcrumb topping, cayenne pepper sauce (like Frank’s original sauce – not Frank’s buffalo sauce, as it contains a ton of processed ingredients), blue cheese crumbles.
• If you’re nervous about overcooking the cauliflower, manually release the pot after 2 minutes. If the cauliflower isn’t cooked yet, close the pot back up and allow it to sit for a couple more minutes before checking it again.
• If adding a breadcrumb topping, I highly recommend adding the recipe to a baking dish and putting it under the broiler for a few minutes to crisp it all up.

Healthy Eating Plans

Portion Fix/21 Day Fix: This recipe serves: 4. The approximate serving size is 1 3/4 cup (1 cup vegetables and 3/4 cup protein), but I always recommend separating out your recipe into 4 equal sized servings for the most accurate counts.

• Container Counts for the entire recipe: 6 red containers, 4 green containers, 1tsp (it’s so little that I don’t add this to my final counts), 4 blue containers, 2 tablespoons brown rice flour. The brown rice flour is not on the food list, but based on the ingredients and nutrition information, counts as 1 yellow container for 1/4 cup. 2 tablespoons equals 1/2 yellow container. Over four servings, I think this is so little that I don’t count it.
• Container counts per serving: 1 1/2 red containers, 1 green container, 1 blue container.

2B Mindset:

This is a great dinner option for the 2B Mindset nutrition plan because it’s got lean protein and veggies. If you’re eating this for lunch, pair it with an FFC.

Weight Watchers:

Using fat free cottage cheese and Greek yogurt, the counts for this recipe are 6 Blue Points | 8 Green Points | 6 Purple Points. 

The points for the new 2022/2023 points plan is 2.

Trim Healthy Mama :

This is an S recipe when you use one of the following instead of the brown rice flour: Xanthum Gum, Glucomannan Powder, or oat fiber.

More delicious Instant Pot recipes

• Healthy Buffalo Chicken Dip
• Instant Pot Buffalo Chicken Bites
• Instant Pot Mac and Cheese
• Vegetarian Stuffed Peppers
• Healthy Veggie Quesadillas